Content

tagged: live cinema

About the live in Live Cinema

An investigation into the liveness of Live Cinema.

  1. September 2010 Presentation of v1 at Laika, Berlin
  2. November 2010 Presentation of v2 at Interaction, Media and Communication Research Group, Queen Mary, University of London
  3. November 2010 Presentation of v3 at VJing Research Panel, Goldsmiths, University of London
  4. April 2011 Presentation of v4 at Interdivisional program in Media Arts and Practice, University of South California
  5. April 2012 4,000 word Essay for Department of Drama, Queen Mary University of London
  6. March 2013 Presentation of v5 at Live Cinema Foundation’s AV Assembly #1
  7. June 2013 Presentation of v5 at Realtime Visuals Syposium, Goldsmiths, University of London
  8. April 2016 Presentation v5 at Test Card Manchester.
  9. February 2018 Presentation v6 at The New Projectionists, Birmingham

The latest slide deck and essay can be downloaded at the bottom of the page. An early recording of this presentation is on vimeo.

Works referenced in the presentation –

Outside the Box: New Cinematic Experiences, a documentary by Seth Thompson

Live Cinema Documentary

RBN_ESC

project | 2010 | downloads: spark-abouttheliveinlivecinema-v5.pdf · spark-abouttheliveinlivecinema-v6.pdf · tobyharris-aboutliveinlivecinema-2012.pdf · vjingresearch_programme.pdf

Live Cinema Documentary

Utter brilliance: finally, our friend toby*spark has documented live cinema and visualism with a medium that reflects the concept. Music and video are presented as frames within frames, manipulated and placed interactively. It’s part fiction and illusion, of course, but that won’t stop you from dreaming as you watch of interactive audiovisual software that did behave fluidly. I could say more, but just watch it. The video says it all.
createdigitalmotion.com

An “experimental documentary about a contemporary arts practice” made as part of my first year on the Media and Arts Technology doctoral training programme at Queen Mary, University of London. Having chosen Live Cinema as my practice - how could I choose anything else - the challenge of the film was to represent a form that is overtly broken out of a pre-determined, linear, framed format in a format that is.

I initially planned a fairly straight-and-structured documentary, chaptered Oral Storytelling > Cinema of the Imagination > Expanded Cinema / Soft Cinema > Cinema and Performance > and so on. Not wanting to make an hours worth of TV, and with Lara going “process! process! process!”, the happy moment was suddenly wondering why the hell I wasn’t doing a =ff=: a gonzo journey around London meeting my practitioner peers that transforms itself into a live cinema performance.

The film that did get made was one that, I hope, walks a line between a novel narrative device - the live cinema interface i’ve been scratching away at for years - and showing the potential of the form with a minimum of words and a maximum of the works themselves. The film is a visualisation of the interface of a *spark cinema instrument/machine if somebody were to come up and start exploring it.

Its been a slog, I’ve tackled this one solo instead of as a pair as intended by the course, and made an manhours-doubling graphics/animation job for myself on top of the edit, so there is still work I’d like to do to truly deliver on the concept, but as I hit the deadline I think it, at v06, holds together. The big omission is a setting-shot of the interface in-situ with the person walking up to it, or perhaps having this as the pay-off at the end. That will take some organisation at the next impressive multiscreen gig!

I hope to make this an on-going project, featuring more artists and works, and I want to explore more the double layer of information coupled with editor’s thought process on top of the actual film as output this narrative device can deliver. The end section should really illustrate the wealth of interview statements I have and how that is boiled down into the edit with downloading, cutting and looping of the performance’s documentation, with a reprise of the montage-on-a-beat BPM lead interface the doc opens with. And while we’re here, there’s a good day or so for me to spend with an audio-head massaging the sound. I really would welcome feedback on what should be worked on to lift up, or ideas for development. A documentary that writes the Wikipedia page on Live Cinema… mmm…!

The words and works in order are:

Toby Harris as *spark - http://sparkav.co.uk

Paul Mumford - http://labmeta.net

  • “The Story Collector”

Michael Faulkner - http://dfuse.com

  • “Particle”

Christopher Thomas Allen - http://lightsurgeons.com

Thanks to the film department at Queen Mary for being great, both with the brief and how it was delivered.
Filming thanks to D-Fuse for use of the 1080P Sony EX3 camera and Sarah Matthews for assistance that day and interested-outsider perspective beyond that.

As the film is screen graphics based, and I can’t escape designing thin white lines on black, its best viewed at the full 720P uploaded to vimeo rather than the embed below. Click through the vimeo link here or in the embed.

project | 2010 | downloads: tobyharris-livecinemadoc-promo.zip

choose your own documentary

got into a sneak industry showing of choose your own documentary. it’s a bona-fide branching narrative, audience-interactive film. and it’s great.

it’s also so perfect a concept, it conjures the slightly uncomfortable thought that rather than than trailblazer for the field, it might just be the one-and-only definitive article. but, no. the conceit relies on such a limited demographic, to start. and… well, is it really an interactive film? my take is that it is simply good theatre, executed with the best audience-voting slide-deck ever. the protagonist-narrator on stage is key, emotionally and in terms of audience interaction.

also –

diary | 18 jun 2018 | tagged: live cinema

doc fest » expanded and live

Artists Christopher Thomas Allen, Katharine Vega and Toby Harris have forged new forms of events, collaborated across the arts, and embraced cultures and technologies old and new. Join them for an exploration of audio-visual performance, projection design and a whole lot of provocation about what the ‘live’ in Live Cinema can be.

diary | 09 jun 2018 | tagged: live cinema · talk · *spark | downloads: livecinemasummit-expandedlivetalk.png

doc fest » live cinema summit

to sheffield doc fest for the live cinema summit.

diary | 08 jun 2018 | tagged: live cinema

the new projectionists

to birmingham, invited to give my talk about the live in live cinema at the new projectionists. formative place, brum.

diary | 24 feb 2018 | tagged: live in live cinema · live cinema · talk · research · *spark | downloads: uk05-poster.jpg

splice » live cinema panel

was part of the live cinema panel, with chris allen, sally golding and lisa brook. chris, sally, and i have talked on this before, but new and outside-of-our-scene is lisa’s live cinema org.

here’s a moment from the talk, as i recall it:

lisa – come to the sheffield doc fest, we’re curating live performances and there’s budget

chris – what! they’ve been turning down live work for years. it’s been maddening.

i mention this as it might mark the point where live cinema pieces (a wide definition per lisa, but including what i’d say and like to see) might start to be commissioned and appear in more mainstream contexts.

diary | 27 may 2017 | tagged: vj · live in live cinema · splice festival · talk · live cinema · *spark

splice » 1024 architecture

what might the final part of a trilogy be, when the first part was so definitive? is there anywhere else to go?

the answer, of course, is something different, something bonkers. not the mise-en-scene and future-props (neon-tube-guitars, anybody?), but a journey through a warped world. a more conventional setup, but much more mind-warp. nice moment afterwards when franz goes “narrative, yes. who was talking about that the first? you.”

good to see old friends continuing to push it. what they were doing the first time i met them, a decade back, is still something i talk about.

diary | 26 may 2017 | tagged: vj · splice festival · live cinema

splice » latitude

diary | 05 jun 2016 | tagged: vj · dfuse · splice festival · live cinema

the live in live cinema at test card

invited up to manchester to give a talk at test card.

Test Card is a community exploring the developments in new software, technologies and techniques in the area of audio visual performance.

given i’d recently revived rbn_esc, seemed only fitting to do ‘about the live in cinema’ followed by a performance of the piece you see in the film.

diary | 27 apr 2016 | tagged: live in live cinema · talk · live cinema · *spark

rbn_esc at av depot

was invited to perform ‘rbn_esc’ at vjlondon’s first big gig: ‘av depot’. to the organiser, it’s a piece that stood out from times past as something deeply audio-visual, considered and executed as one. so it was nice for the invite to be motivated like that, and it was nice – if surreal, somehow – to go through the process of resurrecting the piece, seeing what my former self had been up to, some ten years later.

photo credit: fabrizio d’amico

diary | 05 dec 2015 | tagged: *spark · vj · rbn_esc · live cinema · resolume

massive attack vs adam curtis

to manchester for the premiere of manchester international festival ‘film-gig’ commission massive attack vs adam curtis. well worth the train.

thought one: amazing talent behind one show doubled upon with horace andy, liz fraser, and the powerhouse of uva.

thought two: amazing audience numbers, 1,200 people each night for eight nights has to be a live cinema record?

thought three: if you deliver a two hour single screen edit while talking up ‘a new kind of event’ something went wrong

hope to see the piece develop, such potential between curtis threading of story and the multi-screen presentation of archive.

diary | 04 jul 2013 | tagged: vj · live cinema · massive attack

b-seite » particle experiment

b-seite charge two: a performance. it’s good to do things away from the stresses of big theatres, to be able to experiment amongst your peers. and wonderfully, there was mesh, smoke machines and the very capable tim vis. there’s a one minute video on vimeo.

diary | 23 mar 2013 | tagged: particle · dfuse · *spark · vj · b-seite · live cinema

live cinema foundation » av assembly by night

after the talk and panel discussions on live cinema itself and what role the LCF could or should play, an evening of performances. limited to a single screen, scott amoeba did a wonderfully restrained remix of the documentary kanzeon into a meditative contemplation on the ritual texts. very much my kind of thing.

that said, what made my heart race was the performance that though theoretically limited to the event’s single screen certainly wasn’t. sally golding hauled in a load of old projection gear, assembled it in the middle of the space, and coaxed an audiovisual show out of celluloid and mechanics. it was less about what was on the screen, than how the whole venue was transformed with light leak textures and sally’s shadow swooping around as she literally embraced the setup with body and arms.

diary | 17 mar 2013 | tagged: live cinema foundation · vj · live cinema

live cinema foundation » av assembly by day

the live cinema foundation finally hits the ground with ‘av assebmly’. an idea much talked about over the years between various london folk, chris found the kind of venue that could incubate work, and made a booking on spec. jump-cut a month later, and i’m presenting ‘about the live in live cinema’ to an on-topic audience as you can get.

diary | 17 mar 2013 | tagged: live in live cinema · live cinema foundation · vj · talk · live cinema

lpm'12 » live cinema scope session

to rome for live performers meeting, once an annual institution for me. a weekend in a nightclub is always a strange thing, but being in roma with friends old and new cuts through all. some of whom were old visual berlin types staking out interviews on the rooftops for their new scope sessions project. picture are valerie and david talking about node and vvvv. before that, the light surgeons and i happily bantered back and forth around live cinema past and present… the kind of conversation that just doesn’t happen in the london day-to-day.

diary | 02 jun 2012 | tagged: vj · live performers meeting · live cinema

the live in live cinema redux

from the big revision of the presentation to a write-up that took it in a quite different direction to now: a ground-up re-write. a scholarly work that builds an argument and from the theory offers provocations back to the practice. spoiler: smartphone screens. tl;dr: play your audience not your computers. put out there in a spirit of debate: all crit welcome!

Live Cinema is a contemporary performance practice built around audio-visual media. This essay questions the ‘live’ in Live Cinema, asking what Live Cinema events can tell us about liveness, and what liveness can tell us about the practice. Here’s why:

I’m at a Live Cinema event, but I’m troubled. This is an important moment: my collective has been invited to The School of Cinematic Arts, University of South California; the event is explicitly labelled a Live Cinema one. To my mind, Hollywood might just as well have said ‘hello Live Cinema’! Watching the opening performances, I see an audience rapt. Coming off stage after our performance, big cheers. But this audience… this audience appreciated the content, the staging, but what here was really live? The fact that I was behind a laptop screen pressing buttons? Moreover, I can’t help but feel the audience would have got a better show if we’d played out a recording of our rehearsal, and checked our email instead. Something is wrong here, and having taken on this label of Live Cinema, we owe ourselves and our audience an investigation.

This personal account of the author highlights that Live Cinema is gaining acceptance, is appreciated, but answering what that appreciation is for may not be straightforward. One thing is for sure: as a performance form whose ‘product’ is media and whose ‘draw’ is liveness, it should be an instructive study given an opposition of these two terms has shaped much of the literature on liveness.

diary | 29 apr 2012 | tagged: live in live cinema · research · qmat · live cinema

...to concrete bunker

warmed-up from the apple store gig, its down into a concrete bunker for two d-fuse sets at the redsonic festival. small, intimate and stuffed with 50 speakers in a surround sound dream, its quite the gig. matthias rocks out, his musique concrète scores now chasms of sound; latitude is the immersive drift that totally captured the audience, the trip of particle finally is (how else to describe it?/) dancing in abstraction to the music, and mixes to a finale of new work by paul that in drawing the audience back into a breathing-like minimal simplicity had them in the palm of his hand. gasps and whoops: nice!

diary | 27 jan 2012 | tagged: dfuse · vj · particle · live cinema

d-fuse: shopfloor...

with mike sharpening his critical muscles doing an information environments mres, there’s not been much d-fuse action since los angeles earlier in the year. but here we are, in an apple store for latitude – not quite the theatrical staging, but oh my: the slightly surreal setting disappears upon using the new generation of laptops in anger for the first time. vdmx b8 + quad core i7 + latest radeon + ssd = finally, flawless performance for us. the ghost of perfectly smooth hardware playback has been hanging over my head since moving us to a software setup is banished in a blaze of compositing and audio-reactive tweak. happy days.

diary | 26 jan 2012 | tagged: dfuse · vj · live cinema

the live in live cinema in 4,000 words

having just overhauled the ‘about the live in live cinema’ presentation for the IMAP seminar, i thought it should be quite straightforward to translate this into a 4,000 word essay – my penance for sitting in on a module from QMUL’s excellent drama department last semester. how wrong could i be, the structure to my argument turned out quite differently. all the better for it, however.

Three silhouettes, bodies poised above glowing buttons; a piercing light scanning light beams across the void of the image. ‘Rhythms + Visions: Expanded + Live’ says the text. Flipping the flyer over, the venue as School of Cinematic Arts, University of South California lends an air of authority, and finally in the body text a definition: ‘a live-cinema event’.
I was there — in fact, I am one of the silhouettes on the flyer — and the ‘live-cinema event’ shall frame the following discourse on liveness, media-based performance, and how the role of performance in a true live cinema needs to be rethought.
Walking into the School of Cinematic Arts, there was no being led into the dark of a cinema theatre, rather this would be an exploration through the outdoor spaces of the complex. Moving image works were aligned onto the architecture, and scrims echoed projections in space. Finally, a stage area. The first act starting: Scott Pagano accompanied by four musicians. For the unconventional setting thus far, this is a setup all will recognise: there is what could be termed a cinema-grade screen with performers in front, and rows of seating laid out beyond.
The musicians are playing, seemingly consumed by their instruments and keeping in check with each other. Pagano is standing, the only one twisted around to face to the screen rather than audience. In his hands, an iPad upon which — and with — he is furiously gesturing. On the screen an abstract composition unfolding, organic forms built out with photographic elements, a triumph of aesthetic. The music is instrumental and amplified, without naming a genre it’s accessible to the Los Angeles audience: guitars, keyboards, percussion. The audience seem receptive; there is a pleasing fidelity and sheen to the work.
But what here is live? But what here is cinema? These are the questions in my mind as I watch, and to which we will return.
Next a performance from the collective of which I am part, but not a piece with my direct involvement; I am still in the audience. Endless Cities by D-Fuse. It is a film in the Ruttman and Vertov tradition, a montage of urban scenes from around the world, and is accompanied by a live score: musique concrète performed from laptop with percussion accompaniment. Again it seems accessible, and in the photographic detail there is much to latch onto and be absorbed by.
It’s Live Cinema in the sense that I first heard the term: a musical accompaniment to a silent film. A montage from the kino-eye, it’s easier here to answer ‘what here is cinema’ than the Pegano piece. But I still wonder, what is really live here, and why bother?
The final performance is in many ways my creation, and so here I cannot report from the audience, but can offer my view as a performer. Which is one of immense frustration. Starting out, I am in a good position: we have an expanded staging that breaks the imagery out of the single frame, a developed aesthetic that abstracts footage in sync to the music, and the impressive shot bank of Endless Cities to pull from. It’s less the dérive and more the impressionism of a late night taxi ride. And we’ve performed it really well before. But that is precisely what is killing me by the end of this particular performance. We have performed it better before, so wouldn’t a recording of that performance have served us better? It’s a recognition that performance in this context translates entirely to the audio-visual output, for our actual performance is opaque to the audience, operating somewhere between obscure symbols on an obscured screen and twitching trackpad fingers. At which point, rather than taking the best performance so far to play back, I ask myself why not just create a master version in the studio and be done with it?
This is the terrain from which I argue. My motivation is not to categorise art or debate concepts, but to get to the heart of what a true live cinema could be.

The essay needs a revision – given the time constraints its really just a first draft – for which 'about the live in live cinema’s next outing should provide, whether that is website, journal, seminar or lecture.

diary | 03 may 2011 | tagged: live in live cinema · research · liveness · qmat · live cinema

1

2

3

4